Skip to main content

5 unique Christmas dinner ideas so amazing they’ll become new family traditions

Christmas is all about traditions — from treasured family decorations to Grandma’s cookie recipes, right down to when and how you open your Christmas presents. But if the idea of another Christmas dinner of turkey, baked ham, and all the fixings has you saying “bah humbug,” we have some ideas that are definitely thinking outside the Christmas box.

If you’re ready to break the cookie-cutter mold of traditional holiday meals, we have an assortment of unique Christmas dinner ideas that will inspire your taste buds and bring your holiday meal to a whole new level. Want something a little bit different for Christmas? Try these menu ideas.

Related Videos

Buffet-style Christmas dinners

When you have more dinner guests than you have dining chairs, or when you expect visitors to drop in at various times throughout the day, a buffet dinner gives you the opportunity to treat your guests to a more casual (yet still elegant) Christmas dinner. 

Christmas tacos

Everyone loves tacos, so why not have them as part of your Christmas Day feast? A Christmas taco buffet works particularly well if you’re hosting a larger crowd, where a sit-down dinner might not be feasible. And, these aren’t just ordinary, everyday tacos. This Christmas taco recipe features braised short rib beef and a holiday-worthy pomegranate pico topping. 

The short ribs get their tenderness in a slow cooker (so the cooking happens while you’re busy doing other fun holiday things), with pomegranate juice, chiles, and cinnamon giving it a unique flavor. Fresh pomegranate seeds are used to make a flavorful and colorful pico that provides the finishing touch. Set up a taco-building station for guests, with corn tortilla, cilantro, lime, cotija cheese, crema, and other toppings.

Christmas pasta

Pasta is always a good way to feed a large crowd: It’s hearty, tasty, and when you follow this Rachel Ray recipe, it’s absolutely irresistible! As a bonus, you can make the sauce on Christmas morning or even a day or two in advance. With pancetta, hot Italian sausage, ground beef, pork, and veal, this meat-lover sauce will be an unexpected yet delicious way to refresh your standard Christmas menu. Plus, no many how many times you reheat it, the sauce only gets better and better, so you can whip up batches of pasta for last-minute drop-ins (use about half a pound of pasta for every three people). 

Add a big salad and a few loaves of crusty Italian bread for a filling comfort-food dinner that will feed holiday guests without stressing you out as host.  

Make-ahead Christmas soup buffet

Nothing beats a steaming bowl of savory soup on a blustery winter day. Set up a make-ahead holiday soup buffet with two or three different soup varieties (make sure one is meat-free for your vegetarian guests). Then line up the pots, soup tureens, or Crock-Pots with ladles, stacks of sturdy bowls, spoons, and festive cloth napkins.

Place baskets of bread or rolls on the buffet table, island, or countertop, and provide an assortment of toppings and garnishes, including popcorn, croutons, goldfish crackers, chopped fresh herbs, grated cheese, sour cream, and even salsa, depending on your soup varieties. Looking for a new soup to try? Add this delicious broccoli cheddar recipe to the assortment of some of your tried-and-true soup recipes. 

Sit-down Christmas dinners

Always better for smaller numbers of holiday guests, a sit-down dinner lets you bring out your fancy or holiday-specific china and set a splendid table complete with cloth linens and Christmas-themed napkin rings.

Cumin-spiced roast chicken 

If your Christmas crowd is too small for a turkey or ham, but you still want to do a sit-down dinner, this roast chicken with pork and pistachio stuffing is just right for a family of four. Way more special than a standard roast chicken recipe, this one has salted pistachios for amazing flavor and texture and a spice rub that’s mixed with sweet grape molasses for crispy, flavorful skin. Add garlic roasted potatoes, some roasted root vegetables, and a side salad for a filling and delicious meal that is worthy of the Christmas holiday.

A vegetarian Christmas

While roast beef, turkey, and ham may all be popular holiday dinner choices, a meatless meal can be every bit as festive, delicious, and filling. We’ve pulled together a few drool-worthy vegetarian Christmas dinner recipes that are sure to please your holiday guests — even the die-hard meat-lovers! Get ready to wow with this meat-free holiday meal featuring caponata flatbread, warm roasted cauliflower and spinach salad, and butternut squash and turmeric soup. You won’t miss the meat one little bit. 

Sure, Christmas is a time for traditions, but our outside-the-box dinner ideas may very well be the start of new holiday traditions you’ll continue for years to come. With family and friends around to share the joy of the season, your home-cooked cuisine will form the backdrop for new Christmas memories. 

Editors' Recommendations

7 incredible crockpot chicken recipes that take no time to prep
No time, no problem. These crockpot chicken recipes are quick and easy to make
Woman prepping chicken

If you often find you have no time to cook for yourself, you definitely need to buy a Crock-Pot. Crockpots allow you to make home-cooked meals even on busy days when you're running around from work to activities to home. Most crockpot recipes take very little time to prep, and some have just a handful of ingredients. Just pop them in before you leave in the morning and when you get home, you'll be greeted with a home-cooked meal. 

Now, if you're wondering if a slow cooker is the same thing as a crockpot, you've come to the right place. A crockpot is a type of slow cooker, but not every slow cooker is a crockpot. The term "crockpot" refers to a specific brand of stoneware pot (Crock-Pot) surrounded by heating elements. Someone traditionally made a slow cooker of metal and sits atop a heated surface. Both cook food slowly over hours, producing amazingly tender, hearty meals.

Read more
How to store Thanksgiving leftovers so they last (plus 5 tasty recipes)
Turkey, stuffing, and more. Here's how to store your delicious Thanksgiving food for later
Roasted turkey and side dishes on a table

It's that time of year again! You shopped, you cooked, and you ate (and then you ate some more) — you conquered Thanksgiving. But even with careful planning — not to mention the worry that you wouldn’t have enough food — every Thanksgiving you somehow always end up with leftovers. Lots of leftovers. 

Not that we're complaining, of course! Most people probably agree that Thanksgiving leftovers are one of the best parts of the overindulgent holiday. Leftovers offer you another opportunity to enjoy all that tasty food again… and again. But if you’re not sure what to do with all that food, relax — we’re here to help. We’ll tell you exactly how to make the most of your Thanksgiving leftovers — from safe storage ideas to creative recipes that go well beyond the basics. Let’s talk turkey… and more!

Read more
4 insanely good sides that come together in 10 minutes or less for Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving isn't all about the turkey - These sides are delicious and quick
Family eating Thanksgiving dinner

Thanksgiving is all about bringing family together and eating an indulgent meal filled with everyone's favorites. Once you have the main protein figured out (turkey, ham, prime rib, etc.), you need to fill the table with side dishes that accompany the main.

Since preparing a bunch of Thanksgiving sides at once can be a daunting task, it helps if you can work in some super fast recipes, so you’re not tied to the kitchen all day. Besides, Thanksgiving is about food and family, so you’ll want to actually spend some time with your guests. The four recipes below come together in 10 minutes or less and are good enough for any Thanksgiving table.

Read more