Skip to main content

These easy recipes will give you the traditional Christmas dinner you crave

The best tried-and-true holiday recipes for a traditional Christmas dinner

The holiday season is a magical time, but it also gets pretty hectic. Between shopping, wrapping, baking, and going to parties, some of the most beloved traditions can get lost in the shuffle. Trying new ways to decorate your home for the holidays or experimenting with trendy Christmas recipes is always fun, but there’s something so comforting about returning to some classic Christmas dishes.

If you’re hosting this year’s holiday celebration and looking for some fresh ideas for dinner, why not look to the past? We’ve compiled some of our favorite traditional Christmas dinner ideas to make this your most merry and bright gathering ever.

Christmas eggnog
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Christmas cocktails and appetizers

Eggnog

When it comes to holiday beverages, you can’t get much more traditional than eggnog. Homemade eggnog is surprisingly simple to make and doesn’t include all the fillers or preservatives you’ll find in the store-bought kind. It’s basically just cream, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, and spices. For the adults, you can spike it with alcohol — rum, whiskey, or brandy — or keep it classic for a kid-friendly version that the whole family can enjoy. 

Recommended Videos

Roasted chestnuts

As the opening line of The Christmas Song, chestnuts roasting on an open fire have long been a part of Christmas holiday traditions. Once roasted, chestnuts develop a delicate, slightly sweet flavor, and a soft texture reminiscent of sweet potatoes. While some would argue that the best way to roast chestnuts is over hot coals in a fireplace or in an outdoor fire pit, not everyone has access to either of those, so this recipe gets the job done right inside your oven.

The recipe has one ingredient: chestnuts. Roast them in a 425-degree oven for about 20 minutes and that’s all you need to give your guests the taste of traditional Christmas. Serve on a platter to enjoy as is, or add them to other traditional Christmas recipes like stuffing or tarts.

Holiday dessert
NoirChocolate / Shutterstock

Holiday main course and side dishes

Beef Wellington

Had your fill of turkey at Thanksgiving? Why not make a traditional Christmas roast with an elegant flair instead? Named after the Duke of Wellington, this traditional British main course is beef wrapped in pastry and surrounded by savory duxelles, a mixture of mushrooms, shallots, and thyme. This modified recipe lets you save time and aggravation by using store-bought puff pastry (no one will know the difference). While certainly not the easiest recipe to master, it is guaranteed to absolutely ‘wow’ your guests. 

Maple ginger glazed carrots

There are ordinary side dishes, and then there are side dishes like this one. This mouth-watering dish has the power to elevate the humble carrot into a true taste sensation. It’s super easy to make, but be sure to use fresh ginger root and sweet maple syrup for the best results. Kids certainly won’t have trouble eating their vegetables when this is on the table.

The best mashed potatoes

Everyone loves mashed potatoes, but when a recipe touts itself as being “the best mashed potatoes” we stand up and take notice. In addition to the expected butter, milk, and seasonings, this recipe includes cream cheese and garlic, along with a few other notable flavors, to give you the most crowd-pleasing holiday mashed potatoes this side of the North Pole. 

Holiday dessert
NoirChocolate / Shutterstock

Quintessential Christmas desserts

Putting aside the controversial holiday fruitcake, there are other classic Christmas desserts you should add to your meal this year. 

Yule log cake

Also known as a Buche de Noel, this dessert starts with a chocolate sponge cake which is filled with mascarpone whipped cream and rolled into the shape of a holiday yule log and covered with chocolate ganache. Sound decadent? That’s because it is. 

Figgy pudding

Figgy pudding is mentioned in more than a few Christmas carols, and for good reason. This sticky, sweet traditionally British dessert made from figs and dates is delectable and surprisingly simple to make. Baked individually in ramekins and then coated with a sinfully sweet sauce just before eating, figgy pudding is best when topped with vanilla ice cream or heavy cream. 

Gingerbread cookies

For a kid-approved Christmas dessert, there is no better option than gingerbread cookies. The distinct flavor comes from the combination of cinnamon, cloves, ginger, and molasses, but the smiles come from the cute cutout shapes and piped icing decor. Don’t forget to serve them with warm cocoa for the perfect finish.

Whether you add one or two traditional recipes to your repertoire or recreate a classic Christmas dinner from start to finish, these recipes are sure to impress your guests. Homemade meals show your family and friends how much you care about them, and they’re sure to taste the love in each and every bite. 

Kim Renta
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kim has written for Bloomingdales, Movado, and various e-commerce wine sites. When she's not writing about wine and…
Christmas tree lights set the tone for your decor (what you should pick and why)
Tips for choosing the right Christmas tree lights for your home's holiday decor
lit christmas tree with presents under it next to a fireplace

The Christmas season is upon us, and with it, all of the fun that comes with getting your home all decked out for the holiday season. While you may love pulling out your heirloom nutcrackers or festooning your fireplace mantel with garland, bows, and stockings, the main holiday focal piece of most homes is certainly the Christmas tree.

Beautifully decorated with shiny glass balls and ornaments that have been passed down through generations, your Christmas tree can be a personal way to celebrate the season. Regardless of how gorgeous your tree is, or how impressive your collection of ornaments is, nothing has a bigger impact on the look of your tree than your lights. Here's how to choose the right ones.

Read more
8 things no one tells you about hosting Thanksgiving (that they really should)
Advice for hosting Thanksgiving dinner without the stress
Woman holding a turkey on a platter

So, you're hosting your very first Thanksgiving dinner? It’s a rite of passage that’s bound to happen for most of us, and as the most food-focused holiday of them all, it’s no small task. You’ll have side dishes to prepare, desserts to bake, table-setting ideas to sort through, and (of course) the turkey to cook!

From finding the most mouth-watering pumpkin pie recipe to setting a gorgeous table, you’ll have so many things on your to-do list that it’s easy to trip up, especially if it’s your first time. But we’re here to help you make your holiday a smashing success and save you some worry. 

Read more
6 delicious Thanksgiving desserts to make if you kind of hate pie
Not a fan of pie? Try these holiday dessert alternatives this Thanksgiving
Autumn spices, pumpkin, and cinnamon

We admit it: We're big fans of all the fall flavors. And come Thanksgiving, many of those fall favorites are the highlight of the dessert table — whether you prefer apple or pumpkin, there's probably a pie to your liking. Of course, if you're not the biggest fan of pies (we don't judge), it can be disappointing to see this dessert dominate the Thanksgiving holiday.

The good news is that there is a variety of delectable, non-pie, fall-flavored Thanksgiving desserts that you can integrate into your Thanksgiving holiday meal. Whether you enjoy pumpkin but not the pie, or if you prefer something different altogether, you don't need to miss out on a delicious Thanksgiving dessert just because of your unique preferences! Here are some amazing Thanksgiving sweet treats that you can top off your meal with this year.

Read more