Skip to main content

Home ‘improvement’ projects real estate experts say are actually terrible

Taking on a home remodeling project is always exciting, but not every home “improvement” is actually an improvement. Many renovations don’t translate to increased home value and instead wind up costing more time and money. And while customizing your home to suit your needs isn’t always a bad idea, it could come back to haunt you when it’s time to sell.

So which projects aren’t worth the time? We talked to six real estate experts to learn which home upgrades have the lowest ROI. If you’re planning to sell your home soon, avoid these four types of home renovation projects.

Two women planning a kitchen renovation
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Complete kitchen overhaul

For many homeowners, the kitchen is the heart of the home. It’s where residents and guests spend most of their time, making it one of the most important, and personal, rooms. As such, it’s often best to avoid major changes to the room, especially if you’re considering high-end upgrades. Broker Kimberly Jay of Compass said, “If you live in a one- or two-bedroom apartment, there is no need to put in Subzero and Viking appliances. It’s above the buyers’ expectation, and it’s unlikely that they will pay up for your renovation.”

Agent Christopher Totaro of Coldwell Banker Warburg takes it one step further, suggesting homeowners should avoid full kitchen remodels in all circumstances. He said, “A seller would do better to save the expense and stress of such an undertaking and do some light cosmetic improvements, like a new countertop, a simple cabinet refacing, and/or appliance upgrades.”

Personalized upgrades

Any remodeling project designed to suit your current needs could wind up costing you in the long term. According to agent Mihal Gartenberg of Coldwell Banker Warburg, “a renovation project that might hurt your home’s value is one that is so unique to your personal needs or tastes that the vast majority of the public doesn’t value it.”

This could be anything from putting up wallpaper to adding a pond in the backyard. While you may enjoy these features, the next homeowners will likely view them as projects that they have to deal with.

Instead, take agent Karen Kostiw of Coldwell Banker Warburg’s advice and alter the way you view your property. She suggests thinking of your house as a product when you’re planning to sell. “The property inside and outside should be renovated, so it looks clean, fresh, and shows well in line with comparable properties on the market,” Kostiw recommended.

People DIY renovating a room
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Overly ambitious DIY projects

Do-It-Yourself projects may have exploded in popularity over the past few years, but many home projects are better left to the professionals. Though a home remodeling project may look simple on HGTV or TikTok, completing the project on your own is rarely so simple. Homeowners often make mistakes that could lower the quality of the work, creating results that range from ugly to downright dangerous.

Joe Raboine, the outdoor living expert and Director of Residential Hardscapes at Belgard, provides the perfect example: backyard patios.

“Patio designs appear simple and straightforward,” he stated, “but the process of properly designing patio pavers is much more intricate than it seems. It’s easy for nonprofessionals to make simple design mistakes that can make a huge impact on the look and functionality of the patio in the long run, such as improper spacing and incorrect leveling.” Errors like these are costly to correct and could potentially decrease your home’s value, too.

Changes to the floorplan

A large project translates to a significant increase in home value, right? Unfortunately, that is not always the case. Major changes to the floorplan of your house should be done sparingly and only under the guidance of an expert, says Jessica Rae Sommer, the Vice President of Wedgewood Homes + Maverick Design. These types of renovations can include adding or removing rooms, opening up walls, and transforming a room’s layout.

Sommer said, “While each of these renovations can absolutely add value to the home, making the right changes makes the difference between increased value or adding on the future sales price. While many of these may seem like simple enough changes to complete, it takes real expertise to understand special requirements, flow, and how to optimize spaces to add value.”

Not every home remodeling project is worth your time or effort. When planning renovations, it’s crucial to consider your long-term goals for the house and how the upgrades will impact them. If you’re planning to live in your home for many years to come, the home value may not be at the top of your mind. But, if you are preparing to sell your home, you must consider what buyers are looking for before making any significant changes. The experts agree: Avoid changes that appeal to your personal tastes and only complete extensive modifications with the guidance of a professional. By prioritizing renovations with mass appeal, you’re sure to get the most bang for your buck.

Editors' Recommendations

Shannon Cooper
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Shannon Cooper has written about everything from pet care and travel to finance and plumbing in her seven years as a writer…
Modern updates for your old kitchen that won’t break the bank
Inexpensive ways to update your kitchen in the new year
Stylish pink kitchen interior with dining table and chairs

The kitchen is the gathering place of a home. It's where we reconnect at the end of a long day, entertain family and friends, and often spend time working and preparing meals. If your kitchen is in need of a facelift in the new year, but you don't have a large budget to spend on completely renovating it, you just may be in luck. There are plenty of ways to design old kitchen cabinets, decor, and furniture that can pack a big punch.

Inexpensive kitchen updates are easy to find if you do some homework. First, you need a broad idea of exactly what type of look you're going for and make your plans around that. Without an overarching vision, you may find you can't quite land on what to replace and in what order. Here is some inspiration to get you moving in the right direction. Regardless of your style, these items will immediately breathe new life into your old kitchen.

Read more
5 expert tips to personalize your home design in 2023
Get personal with these expert tips for your home's vibe.
Couple planning their living room layout together

Interior design trends shape the way you style your home, but personalization is where you get to shine. Personalizing your home's interior decor is a great way to achieve a vibe by using colors, textures, and materials. The overwhelming tone of 2023 in home design is creating a space where you feel good. If this seems like too broad a statement, keep reading -- we'll have you on your way to personalizing your home design in no time with these expert tips.

Don’t worry about matching
Gone are the days when you must worry about matching colors and textures inside your home. This is excellent news for anyone who always felt their personality was much less tidy than their home’s vibe. Jon Sanborn, the co-founder of SD House Guys, suggests "mixing different metals throughout the house to create a more unique and interesting look." Think brass hardware in the kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Just don't get carried away -- paying no mind to matching colors could get dangerous.

Read more
This is the simple way to incorporate sustainable design when remodeling your home
Do your part for the environment when considering your next remodel
Kitchen remodel plans

When it comes time to renovate your home, there are a lot of decisions to make. Designing your space with your personal style in mind is just the beginning. Cost, DIY vs. hiring a contractor, and schedule all come into play. But what if you also want to incorporate sustainable home designs into your remodel? Considering the environmental impact when making design choices doesn’t have to be difficult at all. Check out some simple ways to remodel sustainability below.

Home design trends have moved toward sustainability and eco-friendly -- recycled materials, low-energy lighting and appliances, organic fabrics and materials, and high-quality indoor air. Katherine Cohen, associate creative director at Interface and FLOR says this means many people are now selecting products from companies and brands that prioritize sustainability and offer environmentally friendly products. And while this may mean paying a higher price for specific products, many people now consider this extra cost a built-in expense of living responsibly.
Reuse, recycle
If you’re worried about cost or remodeling on a budget, don’t worry -- you can still remodel sustainably without breaking the bank. Repurpose, reuse, recycle, salvage, and reimagine your way into environmentally conscious home design. Use reclaimed wood for floors or a bed frame, reuse cabinets and light fixtures when possible, and buy pre-owned decor from garage sales or local secondhand shops.
Buy responsibly
If you’re concerned with the environment, one way to do your part is to cut down on the amount of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) you’re responsible for. VOCs harm the environment by creating smog and also pollute indoor air. Check for brands that have options with no VOCs, or at least go with a brand that has less than 5g/L of VOCs. You can also look into buying appliances that are better for the environment, such as a tankless water heater.

Read more