Skip to main content

5 home design mistakes you’re probably making with your rustic decor

Raw materials, natural decor, exposed stone, and neutral color palettes all come together to create a stunning, rustic design scheme. Though this style can bring a perfect blend of luxury and comfort to the home, it’s quite easy to become swept up in cliches and trends.

These common stylistic mistakes can leave your home feeling overdesigned and maybe even a little cluttered. To keep your home looking thoughtfully designed, we’ve collected the best tips and tricks so you can create a space that feels rustic and not frenzied.

Recommended Videos

Going overboard with the theme

The biggest mistake new designers make is going overboard with the theme. It can be easy to get carried away with all of the details, but this can make the space feel unfocused. This leads to rooms that look kitschy and thematic instead of balanced and full of personality. What’s worse is that these designs tend to ignore practicality, and you end up with a space that functions poorly.

Living rooms are especially susceptible to overly thematic designing. To avoid this, we recommend blending neutral elements, simple decor items, and only using a hint of rustic design throughout the room. For example, consider using a sleek, neutral-toned couch that blends in with the rest of the room, then decorate it with faux furs, a raw wood coffee table, and maybe a leather sitting chair nearby. By picking a few central pieces that are on theme, you can maintain the rustic aesthetic without creating a space that becomes gimmicky.

rustic wood with modern table in living room design
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Lacking balance in the design

Similar to over-theming, many homeowners lack balance in their design scheme. When designing a rustic living space, it’s important to pair these authentic, natural materials with pops of color and accents to break up the neutral color scheme.

For instance, use a brightly colored bohemian-inspired basket to hold plush woolen blankets. Or, place a sleek, glass coffee table in front of your exposed stone fireplace. By incorporating elements from other styles into your design, you can create a sense of balance and cohesion in the space.

Becoming too cluttered

A major con to rustic designs is that they can appear too cluttered. Pairing raw woods of the same color and opting for several plants, patterns, textures, materials, and stonework can lead to a room that lacks focus. Visitors don’t know where to look as they become distracted by the various knick-knacks and decorations. Without pops of color and unique textures to break up the appearance of the space, it starts to look monotonous and cluttered, even if it’s actually pretty tidy.

Additionally, it’s easy to go overboard with the decor, using several jars, vases, rugs, blankets, and pillows to adorn the space. To avoid this, we recommend taking a more minimal approach to your decor. Let the big, natural pieces become the center of attention and adorn it with simpler wall art, decorative vases, and rugs.

Using cheap furniture

Rustic design is all about rich, raw materials. Stunning cut stone, oversize logs, natural woods, leather, wool, and other earthy materials are some of the defining characteristics of rustic design. However, if you add cheap furniture into the mix, you risk losing the natural and authentic appeal of this style.

Avoid plastic furniture, polyester rugs, and cheap picture frames since they’ll stick out like a sore thumb against the more expensive-looking, ornate pieces. You don’t need to blow your budget on the most high-end furniture, but try to avoid pieces that look inexpensive or mass-produced.

vintage chest and coffee set in rustic living room
ESstock / Shutterstock

Opting for decorations that are too “new”

Rustic designs don’t automatically need to be antique, but the two styles do go hand in hand. Rustic pieces should look homey and worn in, so new shiny pieces might not blend well with the other weathered decor. Instead of heading to the furniture store, try purchasing things secondhand or heading to your local antique shop. That being said, authentic antique furniture can cost a pretty penny, so consider aging your cabinets and tables with paint, stain, and sandpaper.

Rustic design is all about cozy cabin vibes. It’s an aesthetic that focuses on natural materials and a laid-back lifestyle. While a rustic scheme is best achieved with authentic pieces, raw woods, and lived-in furniture, you should make it your own by incorporating simpler pieces, personalized furniture, and other small touches. By avoiding a few common design mistakes, you can create a stunning living room that exceeds all your expectations.

Amelia Wilson
Amelia Wilson (author pen name Amelia J. Wilson) is a content writer in Greenwood, IN. She often enjoys topics on…
An expert’s guide to refreshing your dated midcentury modern living room
Here are the best tips to give your space a fresh look
Living room with midcentury modern wallpaper

A midcentury modern living room has remained a popular design choice for many long after it first appeared. The slim, clean lines and symmetry bring order to any room, and the color palette is neutral and inviting. The classic look never goes out of style; however, if you are looking to breathe new life into it, there are a few things you can do to keep it updated but true to the original timelessness of the design.

We asked the experts how to keep things feeling fresh in a midcentury modern home while still holding true to the shapes, colors, textures, and lines that make the style unique. Anna Franklin, interior designer and founder of Stone House Collective, gave us some easy and fun ideas to keep it feeling fresh.
How to keep a midcentury modern living room feeling less orchestrated

Read more
Need design inspo? 9 modern living room ideas you’ll love
Oversized pieces, block colors, and more texture: Here are some design ideas to consider
Living room with multiple types of lighting

If your modern living room is lacking or looks plain drab, you may be considering a redesign. While white walls and straight lines have dominated modern interiors for the past few years, home design is shifting to more quirky additions in our spaces.

So, if you’re looking for some design inspo for your home, we have some modern living room ideas you don’t want to miss.
Opt for a black and white interior

Read more
This unique wall design will make you rethink wallpaper
Wallpaper frames? An interesting concept to consider for your home
Geometric wallpaper with a console table

Wallpaper is becoming trendier in today’s home design, but some people aren’t ready to take the leap and wallpaper an entire room. This DIY project shows how you can add more visual appeal to a room using wallpaper ideas like creating individual "frames."
How to create this framed wallpaper look
@olivebranchcottage on Instagram shared a neat DIY wallpaper idea that she calls "wallpaper rectangles." This fun twist on adding traditional wallpaper to a room helps add visual appeal without being overwhelming. Here’s how she did it.

Pick your wallpaper
First, @olivebranchcottage suggests picking your wallpaper. In the nursery she designed, she opted for a black-and-white pattern depicting nature scenes.
Choose your trim
To create the "rectangles" on the wall, you’ll want to choose some wood trim. The creator chose some from The Home Depot.
Paint the trim the same color as the wall
Next, you’ll want to paint the trim the same color as the wall tone. This creates a greater sense of flow once you add the wallpaper.
Use painter’s tape to outline your design
@olivebranchcottage used painter’s tape to outline the design. This makes it easy to move pieces as needed and readjust until you find what is right for you. Also, she notes that the size and spacing of your rectangles are entirely up to personal preference. For the nursery, @olivebranchcottage placed the tape 5 inches from the ceiling and 5 inches from the baseboards.
Add your wallpaper
The creator suggests using a laser level to keep things even and straight as you place your wallpaper.
Cut your trim pieces
To cut your trim pieces, measure them to the same length as the painter’s tape you used for outlining. The Instagram creator says a 45-degree angle is best.
Use a nail gun to attach your trim pieces to the wall
Using a nail gun, attach your trim pieces to the wall. You should do this after you’ve laid your wallpaper. It’s OK if the wallpaper goes beyond the painter’s tape outline you created.
Cut the excess wallpaper
Once you attach your trim pieces to the wall, you can use an X-Acto knife to cut off the excess wallpaper. After you cut all the edges, you’ll have a stunning wallpaper design.
How to style framed wallpaper in a room
Styling the framed wallpaper is up to personal preference.

Read more