Plastic vs. glass: Which food storage container makes sense for you?

While it can come as a shock to some, plastic and glass storage containers are not wholly interchangeable. Each material provides unique benefits when it comes to organizing the kitchen. If you’re unsure which container makes sense for you and your home, it might be time to draw up some conclusions on why these two materials outperform one another in different ways.

Below are our comparisons between glass vs. plastic containers to help you decide which is truly a better option for your kitchen.

Glass is better for the environment

When it comes to durability, longevity, and its ability to be recycled, glass outperforms plastic on environmental impact. If properly cared for, glass can outlast the lifespan of plastic in the kitchen. Where plastic is prone to melting or discoloration, glass remains a durable and long-lasting solution for food storage.

Additionally, glass is one-hundred percent recyclable, and so long as it is properly disposed of, you can recycle glass at a designated facility. Unfortunately, due to the wide variety of plastic products available, many recycling plants only offer recycling to a few types of plastic. Anything non-recyclable is tossed into a landfill, where it remains for many years.

Therefore, glass wins the argument for most environmentally friendly.

glass food storage containers
Angelina Zinovieva/Shutterstock

Glass provides a healthier alternative

When it comes to health benefits and safety in the kitchen, glass is a better material. But, unfortunately, even BPA-free plastics are prone to releasing toxic chemicals if heated. This makes washing, microwaving, and heating plastic containers a threat to your health. Plastic containers are also prone to warping and melting, creating a challenge when placing them in the dishwasher.

Luckily, glass is heat-tolerant and can be microwaved, heated in the oven, or placed into the dishwasher. Since it is non-porous, glass materials do not absorb or release any toxic chemicals or microscopic particles when used.

If you are looking for a food-safe and family-safe storage solution, glass is the better choice.

Plastic is better for packed lunches

For packed lunches, it’s a no-brainer that plastic is better for transporting food. Plastic storage containers are light and easy to carry. You don’t have to worry about the glass shattering or the efforts of lugging around a heavy lunch box. They are especially better for kids who need a lightweight lunch box for school and are prone to accidental spills and drops.

Additionally, plastic containers often come in sets of different sizes, so you can section off sandwiches, snacks, dip, and other treats to create a more effective lunch organization.

Whether you’re taking lunch to work or packing snacks for the kids, plastic is a favorable solution.

If you’re storing leftovers, choose glass

Plastic containers can release chemicals when frozen just as they can when heated. For better food safety, opt for glass.

The right glass containers are freezer and refrigerator safe, meaning they won’t release any harsh chemicals or break if frozen. Some glass storage containers are also leakproof, which offers a tight seal to prevent spills or food from going bad.

If you want a storage container that makes freezer and refrigerator storage easier, choose glass.

food in plastic storage containers
Maria Medvedeva/Shutterstock

When it comes to saving space, opt for plastic

While you can stack and store glassware on top of one another, you run the risk of damaging or breaking the containers. Glass containers also take up a lot of space since you have to lay them on the shelf with care to prevent ruining them.

On the other hand, plastic containers are perfect for stacking. You can also store all of your plastic lids inside one container for more efficient storage. There’s no worry about items falling over or breaking because plastic is a durable material.

Some plastic containers are also retractable, meaning they are built to shrink down into a more compact form for more accessible storage. If you want to save space, plastic is the better alternative.

Choose glass for the aesthetic

If you have an open-style pantry, glass containers and storage solutions are a sophisticated choice. Aesthetically speaking, storing items in glass looks far more put together than storing food in plastic. Furthermore, if you are serving food in a glass dish, it looks much more elegant than doing so with plastic. You also avoid the risk of discoloration or strange smells that plastic containers often absorb.

If you want your kitchen to have an aesthetic appeal, glass is a great option. It’s transparent so that you can see all of your food items without confusion, and it retains its stunning appearance indefinitely.

When it comes down to choosing between glass and plastic, we prefer glass containers for food. They are an aesthetic component of any pantry and are perfect for storing items in the fridge or freezer. We also value glass containers for their non-toxic, non-porous material as stains, discoloration, and toxic chemicals are not something we want to have in the kitchen. Glass is a fantastic material for food storage, and we prefer it over plastic.

Editors' Recommendations