Gas vs. electric stoves: Which one is best for you?

Whether you’re moving into a new home and need a stove or it’s time to replace your old one, deciding which stove is best for you can be tricky. Gas and electric stoves perform the essential function of cooking and baking your food as needed, but they each come with unique benefits and drawbacks.

stovetop and oven in kitchen
Africa Studio/Shutterstock

Installation costs

One of the first things to consider when choosing between an electric stove and a gas stove is the start-up costs. While installing either stove will be costly, it is important to note their differences upfront.

Gas stoves operate by connecting to a gas line to function. The cost of installing a gas stove is dependent on a few vital factors. First, if you already have a gas line in the location you want your gas oven, then you can expect the process to be cheaper. Alternatively, if you don’t have a line at all or the connection needs to be moved, you might expect to pay a bit more. Depending on your situation, you could expect to spend upwards of three thousand dollars to install a gas line and connect it to the oven and stovetop.

Electric stoves, on the other hand, operate through an electrical connection. This is far easier to install if necessary and often requires less time and expense. On average, installing an electric stove can be anywhere from one thousand to two thousand dollars.

If you’re looking to save money with upfront costs, the electric stove would be a more suitable option.

gas stovetop burner with pot
DGLimages/Shutterstock

Operating costs

Thankfully, installation costs are a one-time fee. However, just because you paid for the stove to be put in doesn’t mean the expenses are over. Both gas and electric stoves require additional operating costs throughout the year.

This section is a bit more open-ended. Usage is a variable component and can be difficult to measure for the average household. Additionally, there are several models of electric ovens, and each operates with a different amount of wattage.

To best compare the two stoves in this section, we will use a general guideline that may be expected for each. However, a greater comparison may be gathered by speaking to an expert.

On average, the operating cost of using a gas stove in one month may average to around fifteen dollars. This is the expected price of gas usage a household may utilize during a thirty day period.

Alternatively, an electric stove may cost forty-five dollars in one month as the electrical hookups are less energy efficient than the gas line within a gas oven.

When it comes to monthly operational costs, gas ovens are more inexpensive and more energy efficient.

Time to reach temp

One important consideration between gas and electric stoves is the time required to heat up and reach the desired cooking temperature.

Typical gas ovens take about ten minutes to preheat. The stovetop itself reaches temperature instantly thanks to the direct gas line. As soon as the burner is turned on, the heat is ready to go. However, the downside of a gas stovetop is that you can’t adjust the temperature perfectly. Instead, you have to rely on the height and abundance of the flame to cook your food as needed.

In contrast, electric ovens take on average twenty to thirty minutes to preheat. The electric stovetop can take around ten minutes to reach a temperature hot enough for cooking. The delay comes from the fact that electric stovetops use coils that are heated up by the use of electricity. The most beneficial aspect of electric stoves is that you can often set the desired temperature to the degree and don’t have to worry about variating temperatures of heat fluctuations.

If you want an oven that heats up quickly, a gas stove will be the option for you.

electric stovetop and burner
LightField Studios/Shutterstock

Safety

Safety is a high priority for many people when it comes to choosing a stove. While both gas and electric stoves are much safer today than in the past, there are still some differences between them.

A gas stove has an open flame, which many people find to be a bit dangerous. It makes it easier to set fires to things accidentally or raises worry if young children or animals are present. Gas stoves also operate with a combustible fuel source, which can cause fear in many. This also means that gas stove owners must be aware not to put items like cooking sprays or pressurized items near the appliance.

Electric stovetops are also dangerous. The hot coils can still cause burns if the skin were to come into contact with them. Additionally, some electric stoves will automatically cool when the desired temperature is reached, causing the coils to turn grey and appear unheated. An accidental touch can really hurt.

Furthermore, power outages bring about their own problems. In a power outage, electric stoves are inoperable. However, gas stoves can still be used as they are not powered by electricity.

Safety is a challenging component to measure. Both appliances are safe if you follow the proper care and usage. Still, many people consider electric stoves to be a safer option.

Overall, gas and electric stoves perform the same functions that allow you to cook or bake as needed. They are both generally safe appliances that share many similar dangers one might expect from a tool that provides high temperatures. If you’re choosing between installing a gas or electric stove, the final decision will be up to you and your household’s personal needs.

If you want a more affordable option, the electric stove will be the way to go. Similarly, if you want a stove or oven to operate during a storm or require less operational cost, the gas stove will be best for you. Both stoves provide unique benefits and drawbacks. Ultimately, they are both great stoves that will allow you years of excellent home-cooked meals.

Editors' Recommendations