Skip to main content

How to choose the right mattress

Getty Images

When you start shopping for the right mattress, it may seem like an overwhelming choice. Each aisle you venture down comes with new, confusing descriptions, and even shopping online gets daunting after a few websites. So what should you do when in need of a new mattress?

Since we sleep on them for almost a third of our lives, mattresses are sort of a major purchase. They may not cost as much as a car or house, but they’ll likely be with us almost as long. And considering everyone has a preferred sleeping position, unique issues with back pain, migraines, or joint aches, etc., as well as concerns about the safety of various materials, there’s a lot to keep in mind while hunting for the perfect mattress.

Start with the basics

The best thing to do with a decision like this is: Start simple. According to Dr. Arya Nick Shamie of Santa Monica UCLA Medical Center, the first area of mattress shopping to consider is support. Your mattress should be able to give sufficient support to the spine and keep the rest of the body properly in alignment as you rest. This means it must be the perfect balance of firm and soft.

Shamie underscores the importance of this, stating, “If the mattress is too firm, it will push on … pressure points and take you out of alignment. If it’s too soft, those pressure points won’t be properly supported, so your whole body flops back.” Sleep expert Michael Breus, Ph.D., agrees, confirming that “the right mattress … is one on which you feel no pressure, almost like you’re floating in air.”

The next aspect to consider is mattress material. What is your favorite type made from? If you don’t know, try them out and find out which of the following comprised the most-comfortable options:

  • Memory foam: The most popular types of mattresses you’re likely to find currently involve at least some amount of memory foam. It’s designed to conform to the contours of your body, which is said to alleviate stress on the body’s pressure points. Good-quality memory foam springs back to its original position quickly after you stand up or move away from it.
  • Innerspring: These include a series of supportive steel coils in the core of the mattress that absorb the weight of the body and provide a bit of “bounce” when pressed on. The innerspring is the oldest, most well-known mattress type on the market.
  • Hybrid: This type is a combination of the previous two, including both memory foam layers (or sometimes latex) and innerspring coils with the goal of blending the types for optimal comfort and durability.
  • Latex: Considered to have more “bounce” than other types, the latex mattress is also resistant to dust mites, mold, and mildew, with hypoallergenic properties. These are also known to remain quite cool, and are popular with those who tend to “sleep hot.”

Consider which of these works best with your sleeping position before you go shopping.

Visit a mattress store to try some mattresses, or look for sleep trials online

Getty Images

If you’re able to physically go shop at some brick-and-mortar mattress stores, you can try out the mattresses to see how they feel. How should they feel? If your neck and lower back are in a neutral position together while you’re lying down on the mattress, you’re in proper spinal alignment.

If you can’t go shopping at the brick-and-mortar stores, look for decent sleep trials online. These are usually offered by mattress-in-a-box businesses, or similar direct-to-consumer mattress companies. They allow you to sleep on the mattress for an extended period in order to see how you like it over time, with the promise of a refund if you decide you don’t.

The best sleep trials should run for at least 100 days up to an entire year, and include language explaining exactly what to do if you no longer want your mattress at the end of the trial (sometimes this is found in the FAQs).

Look for natural materials as often as possible

While there are confusing labels that don’t necessarily indicate eco-friendly materials have been used, others are fairly sure to be legitimate. If your mattress has 100% natural, GOTS organic cotton covers, made with OEKO-TEX certified organic wool, is GREENGUARD certified, and is made with foams that are CertiPUR-US certified, you’re probably looking at a high-quality product. Be sure to look up each term used, however, as some companies are attempting to greenwash the mattress industry with fake eco-friendly processes and certifications.

Read some reviews

If you can confirm they’re legitimate, reviews from past customers are worth gold when shopping. While most are probably real, there are always fakes around, too. If you think something sounds too good to be true, run the URL through fakespot.com. It can tell if the reviews are fake and let you know.

Check the warranty

Before purchasing, make sure there’s a warranty and that you actually understand it. High-quality brands offer warranties of at least several years promising full replacement for manufacturing defects or problems that occur during normal use. (Hint: If you spill wine on it yourself or break it doing backflips off the second-floor balcony, the warranty doesn’t apply.)

Skip the box springs unless you really need one

Depending upon the mattress you’re considering, the box spring may or may not be part of the deal. It may be necessary to include it in order to get a certain sale price offered. However, if it isn’t, you may not need a new one. Your old box spring may still work just fine, or you may not need one at all. Give it some careful thought before spending money on a new one unnecessarily.

Once you’ve given all of this your best effort, you should be ready to make a decision on your mattress. Which one do you think you’ll get? Remember to look at any deals on sheets and bedding before you hit the checkout, too. You may end up with a whole new, cozy set for your new bed after all.

Editors' Recommendations

21Oak
The best bread bags to combat stale, chewy loaves
Our favorite storage bags for fresh bread, leftovers, and more
French baguette on linen bread bag on wooden counter top

Nothing is worse than preparing to make a sandwich and opening the loaf of bread to find it old and stale, especially if you went through all the trouble to bake it yourself. Stale bread is unpleasant to eat, and it will quickly throw off your plans and send you to the store for a fresh loaf. To maintain that heavenly taste of freshly baked goods, you need a bread bag that conveniently stores your favorite bagels, brioches, and baguettes for you to enjoy any time the craving strikes.

Whether you make your own bread at home or get your fix from a local bakery, it’s equally important to store your fresh bread properly. You probably already know that refrigeration dries up bread while leaving it out on its own can cause it to spoil quickly. With a reusable bread bag, you can prevent moisture from destroying your bread’s texture and allow it to stay crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Let’s take a look at our choices for the best bread bags.
Blue Donuts Bread Bags
Best overall

Read more
Tired of dirty pool water? These are the best pool filter cartridges for cleaner swimming water
Spend less time and money on filters so you can enjoy your pool
Pool filter

If you have a pool in your backyard, you already know that keeping it clean can be quite a chore. Once you figure out which methods work best for you (climate, water type, etc.), you'll eventually need to replace your pool filter cartridges. This may sound like a simple task, but the type of pool filter cartridge you choose can affect how long the water stays clean, and if you're like most people, you want to replace your filter as little as possible not only for financial purposes but for time-saving purposes as well.

Pool filter cartridges with a higher surface area catch more particles than those with a smaller surface area. Also, a good filter should catch both large and small particles (up to 10 to 15 microns) to keep your water sparkling clean. Better replacement filter cartridges mean fewer oils and chemicals in your water, too, which is better for your skin and the liner in your pool (if you have an above-ground pool).
Pleatco Replacement Cartridge
Best overall

Read more
The best scent boosters for effortless laundry odor control
Scent boosters can remove unwanted smells from clothing in a snap
Woman smelling clean towel

Did you know you can add 12 weeks of fresh smell to your wardrobe with this incredibly easy solution for odor control? If you have gym clothes or sports uniforms that keep that funky, sweaty stink even after washing, bring them back to life with any of these scent booster recommendations. The process is easy — you just add them when you put your dirty laundry in the washing machine! No additional steps to follow.

Incorporating scent booster beads into your laundry routine means less fuss, less stink, and more wear out of your favorite clothes. It also helps prevent that stale closet smell that nobody likes. Save water and time by giving your clothes a second or third round each with this curated selection of the best scent boosters we could find.
Downy Unstopables In-Wash Scent Booster Beads
Best scent booster overall

Read more