Skip to main content

A competitive rental market is pressuring one rural market more than anywhere else

This market is seeing a rise in rental property requests

Reading the paper on an apartment deck

If you live on the East Coast and are looking for an apartment, this probably isn’t news to you: North Jersey is the most competitive rental market in the U.S., and eight of the country’s 20 most competitive rental markets are located in the Northeast. A new report from shows that cities like North Jersey, Brooklyn, New York, and Boston, Massachusetts are in high demand for rental properties after years of sluggishness, pushing rental prices higher and frustrating would-be renters in competition for apartments for rent.

To compile this report,’s team looked at Yardi Systems apartment data across 134 rental markets in the U.S. of “large-scale multifamily properties of at least 50 units.” To give each city a score, researchers looked at apartment occupancy rates, average total days vacant, prospective renters per vacant unit, renewal lease rates, and share of new apartments completed compared with the overall supply at the start of Q4 2022.

Rental markets across the country

Rentals have skyrocketed across the U.S., and not just in the Northeast. In fact, Miami, Florida is second on the list, with a 97% occupancy rate. Cities like Manhattan, New York, Silicon Valley, Los Angeles, and Chicago, Illinois also saw a marked increase in rental competition. On the West Coast, Orange County and San Diego were tied for the “hottest rental market” in California.

The research also showed apartments are, on average, occupied within 38 days and have 8 prospective renters competing for each vacancy. The average occupancy rate of these top 20 cities was 94.2%, and renters renewed their leases 60.7% of the time. When you pair that with the fact that apartments are just 0.43% of the nation’s housing supply, finding a new apartment to rent is becoming a significant challenge.

Why the changes?

With housing prices increasing in the real estate housing market, many are forced to rent versus buy in cities across the country. Compounding the issue is many work-from-homers who are relocating to cities throughout the U.S. and pushing out many in the area. Some of this is from students and others from professions drawn to cities like tech and finance.

Lafayette, Indiana, for instance, is the most popular small-sized rental market, with many of those looking for student housing, as well as faculty staff and residents. The report found similar experiences in other smaller markets, such as Fayetteville, Arkansas and Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania. An increase in transplants coming from gateway cities is also putting pressure on rental markets in states like Wyoming.

If you’re looking to rent and are flexible about where you live, this report gives a wealth of information by state to help you make an informed decision. While it’s not ideal to have to compete over rental properties, it’s good to have the information handy, so you go into the process with an open mind, and hopefully, a bit of patience.

Editors' Recommendations

Julie Scagell
I am a freelance writer based in Minneapolis, MN. My passions include my dogs, talking about my dogs, and taking pictures of…
A startling number of 2022 homebuyers are already underwater – find out why
Black Knight shared data that reveals many 2022 homebuyers have underwater mortgages
Red house with for sale sign in the front yard

It's fair to say that the post-pandemic world has created a confusing landscape in the housing market. With rising mortgage costs, hiking interest rates, and the allowance of reduced down payments for certain borrowers, the number of 2022 homebuyers underwater is increasing at an alarming rate.

Many homeowners are finding they owe more on their home loans than what their properties are worth. And with the threat of delinquency on the rise, this issue becomes all the more concerning. If you're a recent homebuyer, here's what you need to know about the increase in underwater mortgages.

Read more
The house maintenance tasks homeowners think first-time buyers should know
A few considerations when buying your first home
try these 11 bathroom diys you can do in one hour plumber

Buying a home for the first time isn't for the faint of heart. There are so many decisions you need to make and so many considerations to keep in mind before you sign on the dotted line. The biggest worry (beyond the biggest financial investment you're making) is what you don't know, especially regarding house maintenance. Luckily, we have the expertise of those who have come before us.

Redditor theforeverletter recently posed this question on the r/Home Improvement subreddit: "Homeowners who have been doing this for [a while], what regular maintenance do people need to do to their house they don’t know they should be doing? For those of you who know far more than me, I bought a house last year; what things do I/other first-time homeowners need to do to keep up with everything we may not know? Of course, this depends on the house (Septic/city water crawl space/no crawl space) and things can vary, but happy to learn as much as I can!" Hundreds of people were happy to share their advice, and we've taken some of the most popular, so you know what to look out for.

Read more
Sanding, primer, or both? This is how to prepare a wall for painting
Don't skip these important steps before you start your next paint job
Two people painting an interior wall

Painting is the easiest way to transform any room in your home. A simple coat of paint is all it takes to make a drab space become a vibrant, bright room that everyone will love hanging out in. However, when it comes to actually getting the painting job done, there are some preparation steps that you need to consider.

Painting requires a bit of prep work, regardless of what condition your walls are in. Walls with holes and dents may take longer to prep than walls that just need a coat of paint. Additionally, you may need to consider sanding, priming, and other prepping methods that'll help your painting project go smoothly and ultimately result in a stunning, finished look.

Read more