Skip to main content

Avoid a cleaning disaster: When not to use a Magic Eraser

When to use a Magic Eraser and when not to

Magic Erasers are truly incredible for cleaning. They can scrub off that stubborn ring that’s been on your bathtub for ages, make plastic outdoor furniture look new again, or remove scuff marks from your favorite pair of sneakers. However, there are times when your Magic Eraser might work a little bit too well and ruin the very object you’re trying to save.

Even though Magic Erasers look a bit like ordinary sponges, they don’t perform in the same manner. They are a deceptively abrasive and effective cleanser. To ensure your most prized possessions don’t end up in ruins, you need to know when to use a Magic Eraser and when not to use a Magic Eraser for cleaning. 

Melamine sponges on a gray background

How does Magic Eraser work?

Now that we know a Magic Eraser is not a sponge, what is it? It’s actually blocks of melamine foam composed of microscopic air bubbles encased by threads of hardened melamine resin — and it’s every bit as tough as it sounds. Those hardened melamine resin threads are sharp when broken — similar to shards of glass.  

When you rub Magic Eraser across a surface, the blend of melamine resin and those microscopic air bubbles work together to clean, unlike any other product. The resin is the scraper, the air bubbles are the absorber, and if anything survives that powerful one/two punch, a bit more pressure will break the melamine down into even more tiny abrasive particles. It’s like a hand-sanding machine with a built-in vacuum function. 

Two stainless steel pots on stove

When not to use a Magic Eraser

Can you use a Magic Eraser on any surface? Definitely not. There are some surfaces that this cleaning product is too abrasive for.

If you’re at all unsure if you should use Magic Eraser on a specific surface, do a quick ‘patch’ test before committing to the cleaning project. Overall, it’s fabulous at cleaning so many different types of messes around your home, especially in your kitchen and bathroom. Try not to use it on high-gloss surfaces, as the abrasiveness could permanently dull the luster of the finish. While there are plenty of Magic Eraser uses, there are also times you should find another cleaning method.

Magic Erasers don’t magically erase everything — here’s where not to use them:

  • Shiny painted, enameled, sealed, or varnished surfaces. Magic Eraser can strip away the finish.
  • Wood. Magic Erasers can scratch and strip the finish.
  • Your car. You can damage the paint job.
  • Natural stone surfaces, including granite and marble. You can damage the sealant and make your countertop appear lifeless and dull.
  • Non-stick pots and pans. Magic Eraser can scratch the surface, and then that coating can get in your food.
  • Stainless steel. Like natural stone, Magic Eraser can make stainless steel look dull.
  • One-of-a-kind collectibles. If you have something that holds sentimental value, don’t test out Magic Eraser on it. The risk isn’t worth it.
  • Screens. The Magic Eraser would quickly scratch and ruin the screen.
Gloved hand cleaning crayon off wall with a Magic Eraser
Jenn Huls/Shutterstock

What are Magic Erasers safe to use on?

Ordinary dirt, grime, and sticky messes are no match for Magic Eraser. With a simple wipe across the surface, most stains are history. For tougher stains, a bit of extra elbow grease should do the trick. Be sure, though, whenever you use a Magic Eraser, to put gloves on. The surface of the Magic Eraser is abrasive and potentially harmful on skin. And never use a Magic Eraser without doing a spot test first.

Here’s how to use Magic Eraser.

Our dirty dozen list of ordinary cleaning chores Magic Eraser will ace:

  1. Remove scuff marks, crayon, pen, and marker stains from walls and baseboards.
  2. Eliminate baked-on grease and food splatters from oven doors.
  3. Whiten greying grout and bring back your tile’s shine.
  4. Remove layers of soap scum from shower doors.
  5. Make a greasy stovetop shine again.
  6. Scrubs off sticky label residue from wine bottles and glass jars.
  7. Remove burnt-on grime from glass baking dishes.
  8. Eliminate years of build-up from curling irons and flat irons.
  9. Remove rust rings in your tub or bathroom sink.
  10. Wipe away stuck-on splatters inside your microwave.
  11. Make bathroom faucets and handles sparkle like new.
  12. Remove wine or juice stains from Formica counters.

While there is no magic way to avoid having to clean your home, Magic Eraser is the next best thing. In an unassuming sponge-like disguise, this perfect blend of ultra-strong abrasives gets things incredibly clean — faster, better, and easier than you ever thought possible. 

Editors' Recommendations

Kim Renta
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kim has written for Bloomingdales, Movado, and various e-commerce wine sites. When she's not writing about wine and…
The house maintenance tasks homeowners think first-time buyers should know
A few considerations when buying your first home
try these 11 bathroom diys you can do in one hour plumber

Buying a home for the first time isn't for the faint of heart. There are so many decisions you need to make and so many considerations to keep in mind before you sign on the dotted line. The biggest worry (beyond the biggest financial investment you're making) is what you don't know, especially regarding house maintenance. Luckily, we have the expertise of those who have come before us.

Redditor theforeverletter recently posed this question on the r/Home Improvement subreddit: "Homeowners who have been doing this for [a while], what regular maintenance do people need to do to their house they don’t know they should be doing? For those of you who know far more than me, I bought a house last year; what things do I/other first-time homeowners need to do to keep up with everything we may not know? Of course, this depends on the house (Septic/city water crawl space/no crawl space) and things can vary, but happy to learn as much as I can!" Hundreds of people were happy to share their advice, and we've taken some of the most popular, so you know what to look out for.

Read more
This is the secret to drying your clothes: A natural solution you’ll never guess
Find out the scoop on wool dryer balls vs. fabric softeners and dryer sheets
Close-up of a laundry basket and washing machine

Some of the most important factors in our laundry routine are the ones that make our clothes feel soft and smell amazing. Fabric softeners and dryer sheets have reigned supreme for decades, but there’s a new kid on the block when it comes to softening and freshening those fabrics. This is the secret to drying your clothes: wool dryer balls!

If you haven’t heard of wool dryer balls, these handy little puffs are made entirely of natural wool yarn and sort of look like tennis balls -- only a bit bigger. But why would you need balls of wool in your dryer and what do they do? We’re going to talk about how wool dryer balls work and why you need to add them to your laundry routine.

Read more
10 helpful tips to keep bugs out of your apartment or condo
Keep bugs out of your home without calling the exterminator
Dead bug with pest control sign

Cleaning your apartment might be enough to keep your place looking nice, but it may not be enough to keep pesky bugs from making your home their home. Keeping bugs out of an apartment or condo is a different game than keeping them out of a house. When you live in an apartment building or condo that's part of a larger unit, bugs can quickly come from community spaces into your space. If your neighbors have habits that attract bugs, it doesn’t take much for those critters to come into your rooms, too.

Your apartment or condo location can also contribute to the number of bugs in your living area, such as if your apartment is near the woods or close to the outdoor dumpsters. Also, apartment complexes and condos often have several entrances, which increase the chances insects have to get into your home.

Read more