Skip to main content

The ultimate guide for choosing the perfect Christmas tree

It’s almost that time to collect family and friends, hop in the car, and go on a hunt for the perfect Christmas tree. It’s one of the best parts about the holiday season, but picking the right tree isn’t all fun and games. There’s some thought that goes into which tree will fit in your home — both in terms of size and overall style. You also want to make sure you’re getting a healthy tree that will smell divine and last throughout the holiday season.

Consider this your guide to finding and bringing your very own evergreen to deck the halls. Here are a few tips we’ve learned along the way to find the tree that’s right for you.

Christmas tree in room
Oxik / Shutterstock

Which type of tree should I look for?

It can be overwhelming walking through the tree farm as there are about 16 different types of trees that lots sell for Christmas. Some are only available in certain parts of the U.S., but the varieties below are available in most states. Here are a few of our favorites and why we love them:

Balsam Fir

  • The richness of the dark green needles
  • The needles don’t drop or brown
  • Super fragrant evergreen smell
  • The dense, short branches hold ornaments well
  • Typically, the least expensive tree to buy

Fraser Fir

  • Good needle count and doesn’t shed easily
  • Silver underside makes for a shimmery, elegant tree
  • Appears thick and full
  • Slightly less fragrant than the Balsam, which is ideal for those who don’t love a strong scent

Douglas Fir

  • The short, stout size makes for a more manageable tree
  • Paler green than the other firs
  • The needles are softer (tactically and visually)
  • Ideal for sparse, light ornaments

Blue Spruce

  • Gorgeous, full look with few gaps
  • Silvery, bluish color reflects light well
  • Needles are strong enough to hold ornaments (be careful around the sharp inner branches)
Image used with permission by copyright holder

How do I decide which size to pick?

There are a few things to keep in mind when getting the right height Christmas tree.

  • Room height: First, you’ll want to know the height of the room where the tree will live this season.
  • Tree toppers and stands: Make sure to consider how much additional room you’ll need for your tree topper and if you plan to put the tree into a stand or pot. Typically, you should allot 12 to 18 inches.
  • Fullness: Don’t forget to consider the fullness of the tree, as well. If you have a small, narrow living room, find one that’s more narrow (Balsam is good for this).

How do I test the health of the tree?

To ensure a tree will absorb plenty of water throughout the season, buy one that’s freshly cut. If you are buying from a lot, you can tell the freshness by running your hands over the needles, which should be pliable to the touch. If they are dry and brittle, odds are the tree’s been there a while.

Have the lot or farm put it through a shaker or blower to get any dead needles off, and wrap it securely to the car to avoid branches breaking off on the trip home. If you are having one cut for you, drive home right after and get it set and into water.

Make sure you are refreshing the water daily. Letting your tree dry out can lead to premature death and falling needles, and both situations can cause a big mess and become a serious fire hazard.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Once all the work is done, the only thing left to do is decorate your Christmas tree and enjoy the season. Whether you like the old-school bubble lights and strings of popcorn and tinsel or prefer a more formal tree with blues, silvers, and glass ornaments, you really can’t go wrong with your decorations as long as they inspire you.

If you’ve never cut down your own tree before, we highly recommend trying out the experience this season. Just make sure you have all the equipment you need and an extra set of hands to get it back to the car and you’ll be able to tell guests you did all the work to bring home your tree this year. Not only will it ensure the tree is freshly cut, but you will also have the memories of trekking out to the middle of a wooded area, finding the perfect tree (Clark Griswold style), and bringing it home. (Just remember to check for squirrels before putting it in your living room.)

Editors' Recommendations

Julie Scagell
Former Digital Trends Contributor
I am a freelance writer based in Minneapolis, MN. My passions include my dogs, talking about my dogs, and taking pictures of…
Your complete guide to Scandinavian design: A gorgeous, simple home aesthetic
Interested in Scandinavian design? Here's everything you need to know about it
Modern Scandinavian living room style

Whether you want to honor the landscape with natural home decor or cozy up indoors to enjoy the concept of hygge, Scandinavian design offers gorgeous simplicity in the home. This design aesthetic is more than just IKEA furniture. Scandinavian design focuses on functionality and simplicity to help connect us with nature while offering a comforting interior to withstand even the darkest of winters.

For those who want to embark on uplifting their minimalist aesthetics or are curious about this beautiful style, here is everything you need to know about Scandinavian design.

Read more
9 amazing accent wall ideas for your home
These accent wall ideas will add a splash of style to any space
Gray and shiplap accent walls

When it comes to giving your home a fresh and exciting makeover, one of the easiest and most impactful ways to do it is by creating an accent wall. An accent wall is a focal point in a room that draws attention and adds character to the space. It's a canvas for your creativity and can transform the entire look and feel of a room. Let's explore nine amazing accent wall ideas that will inspire you to revamp your living spaces.

1. Bold colors: A classic among accent wall ideas
One of the most timeless and straightforward ways to create an accent wall is by using bold colors in contrast to the other white or neutral-colored walls. Choose a vibrant paint color for your accent wall that contrasts with the rest of the room. This can be a deep blue in an otherwise neutral room or a fiery red in a sea of grays. Bold colors make a strong statement and are an excellent choice for those looking to add drama and personality to their space.

Read more
2024 home design: 9 gorgeous living room decor ideas the experts swear by
Living room design ideas to consider for the new year
Modern living room design with warm taupe paint colors

As we look forward to the new year, many homeowners are itching to uncover the living room decor trends that we can expect to dominate our spaces. From biophilic designs to artisanal pieces, 2024 home decor is all about curating a space that feels “lived-in,” eclectic, and reflects each homeowner’s individual taste and style.

We spoke to the experts to get an idea of the trends entering our living room designs as the year progresses. Here’s what we learned.

Read more