Skip to main content

Ripoff report: Why meal subscription boxes aren’t worth the hype

Meal subscription boxes have become a bit of a trend for young adults or families seeking to cut back on stress when planning a week’s worth of meals. Companies like BlueApron, HelloFresh, and Plated offer many households the convenience of fresh ingredients delivered right to their doorstep.

While this fad has certainly become popular thanks to the pandemic and stay-at-home mandates nationwide, we have to wonder if these services are really worth all the hype.

Recommended Videos

How meal subscriptions work

Meal subscription services are straightforward and easy to use, making them a favorable alternative for busy families. You simply go online or download the company app and sign-up for a scheduled box of ingredients to be delivered to your door. You pay based on the number of meals you’ll need to cover your week or month, and the company sends you the ingredients.

These boxes often include meats, vegetables, fruits, pasta, and other necessary ingredients that you will need to make a dish. Recipe cards are also included, and the only thing you need to worry about is if you have essentials and spices on hand.

meal subscription box on kitchen counter
JJava Designs/Shutterstock

Highlights and drawbacks of this service

The main reason many households favor meal subscriptions vs. cooking is the convenience that the services provide. There’s no need to scroll for hours on Pinterest or food blogs looking for that perfect recipe. Additionally, the stress of creating a list and heading to the grocery store is lifted from your shoulders as the company provides all of the ingredients and an easy-to-follow recipe without any extra work on your end.

Many people enjoy discovering new recipes and relaxing at home while their meal planning is taken care of for them. However, these services come at a fairly steep cost.

Most meal subscription services cost, on average, 10 dollars per person per meal. So, for one dinner each night for a week, a single person might expect to spend 70 dollars. While some meal services like Every Plate offer meals as low as five dollars per person, the cost can still add up quickly.

A look at the environmental impact of food delivery services

One thing many people don’t consider when it comes to these delivery services is the environmental impact that comes with each delivery. Vehicle and production pollution aside, the ingredients often come in layers of packaging to ensure quality freshness.

You might anticipate one box to contain several smaller containers and plastic packaging wrapped around each individual ingredient. This creates a lot of waste that could have been avoided had you bought your produce individually at the grocery store, for example.

Additionally, the cooler-style boxes that these ingredients arrive in are often non-recyclable due to the blended materials and the plastic lining.

meal subscription box ingredients
Daria Nipot/Shutterstock

Why convenience isn’t worth the cost

Since you pay for the convenience of food delivery, you can anticipate that these services will equate to the cost of dining out for each meal. The downside of this is that often, all breakfasts, lunches, snacks, and drinks are still up to you, meaning that you still have to make a trip to the grocery store each week to cover your other meals.

Another issue is that you can’t buy in bulk. These meal subscription plans will send you perfectly portioned ingredients that make just enough for your meal, leaving little to no extras. This often means you’re paying more money for less food. Buying in bulk at the grocery store often saves you money in the long run and allows for leftovers that you and your family can indulge in.

While it’s certainly convenient to be handed new recipes and offered freshly delivered ingredients to your door, you ultimately spend more money overall. It might be best to save some recipes from Pinterest or your favorite cookbook for future reference and then purchase your ingredients from the grocery store.

If you’ve never tried a meal subscription service before, it could be an exciting venture to try out. Save any new recipes you like and in the future, repeat them at a fraction of the cost at your local grocery store.

Editors' Recommendations

Amelia Wilson
Amelia Wilson (author pen name Amelia J. Wilson) is a content writer in Greenwood, IN. She often enjoys topics on…
5 things you should always buy at Costco (and 4 you really shouldn’t)
Person grocery shopping with a Costco membership

We all love shopping at Costco. From the food court to the extra benefits — like the tire center, vision center, and pharmacy — there are plenty of hidden perks of shopping at Costco. But this doesn’t mean you should buy everything there. Here are five things you should definitely put on your Costco shopping list — and four you really shouldn’t.

What you should buy at Costco
Rotisserie chicken
Do we even have to say this one? It’s a ready-to-go meal for the whole family. It costs $5. This isn’t something we should have to talk you into. (You should, however, check out Costco’s other prepared foods and pre-made meals. They’re tasty too, and you can find some good deals.)
Maple syrup
Is there anything better than fluffy, warm pancakes with real maple syrup? Too many syrup options out there today are made with the artificial stuff — highly processed corn syrup or high fructose corn syrup. And when you do manage to find the real deal, it’s pretty expensive. Kirkland’s brand is made with real maple syrup, the kind that comes from the sap of maple trees — and it’s got that signature Costco price. And, according to Epicurious, it holds its own in the flavor department.
Gift cards
Gift cards theoretically should be the same price everywhere — after all, you’re essentially just buying money to spend at another store, right? But at Costco, you can often get them at discounted prices. So be sure to stock up for those last-minute gifts for friends and family. (Or for yourself. We don’t judge.)
There’s been a persistent rumor for years that Kirkland-branded vodka is actually produced by Grey Goose. And while those claims have been denied, it kind of doesn’t matter: If you can get a bottle that tastes like it could be high-end vodka to alcohol enthusiasts and taste testers all over, then that’s definitely a brand worth spending $20 on.
Over-the-counter medications
If you and members of your household have to take acetaminophen, ibuprofen, or allergy pills regularly, buying in bulk makes a lot of sense. You’ll likely go through the bottle before it expires, will spend a fraction of the price, and will never be caught without a little relief again. Keep a smaller bottle in your bag (or wherever’s convenient for you) that you refill from the Costco bottle and you’re good to go.

Read more
10 easy vegetarian casseroles for a no-stress meal
best casserole carriers overhead view of woman holding broccoli while standing at dining table

If you’re looking to experiment with some new recipes, you really can’t go wrong with casseroles. Comforting, hearty, and easy to make, most casseroles can be put together hours before they go into the oven. All in all, these meals are an excellent option for busy weeknights or on days when you don’t have the time to prep, cut, or stand guard over a skillet of ingredients on a hot stove. 

If you’re struggling to find dinner ideas for Meatless Mondays, vegetarian casserole recipes are the one-dish answer you’ve been searching for. Loaded with healthy veggies, and lots of gooey cheese or creamy sauces, these meat-free casseroles will make you the hero to all the vegetarians on the block — and even the non-vegetarians. From mushrooms to potatoes, cauliflower to eggplant, these healthy make-ahead vegetarian casseroles are filling and delicious… so let’s get cooking!

Read more
These easy Easter dinner ideas will make your holiday meal a hit
Easter place setting on table.

Roasted turkey, leg of lamb, or glazed ham are typical Easter dinner favorites. But for those of us who don’t have the time to make those, or who might be hosting a smaller crowd, some of the traditional choices may not be right for us this year. Luckily, there are other options that are every bit as festive and tasty, but just a bit easier to prepare and a whole lot faster to cook.

With a nod to tradition but a practical approach, we looked for recipes that are special enough for the holiday but won’t require you to spend days preparing or hours in the kitchen. With a focus on seasonal produce, and new spins on classic Easter favorites, you can create a memorable holiday meal your guests are sure to love.

Read more