Skip to main content

The dressing that will actually make you want salad this Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving dinner is filled with indulgent dishes like mashed potatoes with lots of butter, mac and cheese, and candied sweet potatoes. And we can’t forget all the delectable pies, cakes, and other desserts. With all of the delicious items on the Thanksgiving table, salad frequently takes a back seat. However, you can change that trend this year with a killer salad dressing. The best salad dressing can turn a regular bowl of mixed greens into a side dish the whole family will love. This salad dressing, often referred to as comeback sauce, is a staple of Mississippi cuisine and resembles a Louisiana remoulade. Give it a try this Thanksgiving, and we promise the salad on the table will not be ignored any longer.

The sauce

Comeback sauce is extremely versatile and tastes delicious as a dipping sauce for fried pickles as well as a dressing spread on a sandwich. Greek restaurant owners created the sauce in Mississippi when chefs realized the need for a spicier sauce to please their southern customers. From there, the sauce exploded in popularity, eventually becoming a must-have condiment that Mississippians proudly claim as their own.

Image used with permission by copyright holder


  • 2/3 cup bottled chile sauce
  • ½ cup vegetable oil
  • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
  • 2 dashes of hot sauce of your choice
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper (freshly ground if possible)
  • 1 tablespoon finely grated onion
  • 3 cloves finely minced garlic
  • 1 cup mayonnaise (the higher the quality, the better)
  • ¼ cup ketchup
  • 1 teaspoon dry mustard
  • ¼ teaspoon paprika
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon celery seed
  • ¾ teaspoon curry powder
  • 3 teaspoons prepared horseradish


  1. Finely grate onion and place in a food processor or blender.
  2. Finely mince garlic cloves and place them in a food processor or blender.
  3. Combine all other ingredients with the onion and garlic. 
  4. Mix all ingredients with one tablespoon of water in the blender or food processor until well combined. 
  5. Taste and season with more salt and pepper if needed. 
  6. Refrigerate overnight to allow the flavors to blend.

This recipe will yield one pint (16 ounces) of dressing and takes just 15 minutes to make. It will keep for up to two weeks when refrigerated in a covered container. You must make this dressing ahead of time and allow it to refrigerate for as long as possible before serving — the longer it sits, the better the flavors will blend, leaving you with a crowd-pleasing, decadent sauce. 

The flavors are perfectly balanced, making a sauce that’s bold enough to be memorable but not so intense that it overpowers whatever it’s paired with. Very popular on shrimp, chicken, and fried fish, the sauce is a crowd-pleaser for sure and will make any bowl of veggies much more appealing.

Family eating Thanksgiving dinner with salad.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Thanksgiving salad ideas

Making a great salad is much more than tossing a bunch of veggies with a good dressing. Some thought should be put into the ingredients you choose for your salad, especially for a special meal like Thanksgiving. As a general rule, look for crisp and fresh veggies, being sure to incorporate different flavors and textures. Use more than one type of lettuce or green in your salad to add more complexity. Romaine lettuce has a great crunch and mild flavor, but it tastes best when combined with bitter and earthy spring greens.

Add chopped cucumbers (peeled and seeded if you prefer) and some red onion for added crunch. Sliced grape or cherry tomatoes will round out the flavors in the salad and add a much-needed pop of sweetness and color to the dish.

Once you have these basics, feel free to use your imagination to finish the dish and specialize it to fit your tastes. For example, many people like hard-boiled eggs in their salad, while others prefer shredded cheese or croutons. Whatever you do, use high-quality ingredients for the best results, grating the cheese and making homemade croutons if you have the time.

Be sure to refrigerate your salad until you are ready to serve it and dress the salad at the table (or just before serving) for the best results. If you want to give this dish the VIP treatment, chill the serving bowls to keep the salad tasting fresh and crisp.

Thanksgiving dinner is a big deal, and nothing is worse than working hard all day on a dish only for it to be cast aside. If this usually happens to the salad on your Thanksgiving table, change the game with homemade comeback sauce. With this unbeatable dressing, you can transform your salad from a rejected dish to a must-have in no time.

Editors' Recommendations

Kelly Kaliszewski
Kelly's work has appeared in blogs and on websites. When she's not writing, she is playing with her two dogs, cooking, or…
7 incredible crockpot chicken recipes that take no time to prep
These crockpot chicken recipes are quick and easy to make
Chicken casserole

If you often find you have no time to cook, you definitely need a Crock-Pot. Crockpots allow you to make home-cooked meals even on busy days when you're running around from work to activities to home. Most crockpot recipes take very little time to prep, and some have just a handful of ingredients. Just pop them in before you leave in the morning and when you get home, you'll be greeted with a home-cooked meal. 

Now, if you're wondering about the difference between a slow cooker and a crock pot, you're not alone. A crockpot is a type of slow cooker, but not every slow cooker is a crockpot. The term "crockpot" refers to a specific brand of stoneware pot (Crock-Pot) surrounded by heating elements. Someone traditionally made a slow cooker of metal and sits atop a heated surface. Both cook food slowly over several hours, and even our quick chicken crockpot recipes produce amazingly tender, hearty meals.

Read more
Blinds vs. curtains: Which should you choose?
A guide to deciding between curtains and blinds
Curtains in large living room

When moving into a new home or redecorating a space, one challenging step is choosing between installing new curtains or opting for blinds. Before you finalize a purchase of either, consider what look you’re trying to achieve. Factors such as cost, ease of installation, maintenance, lighting options, and energy efficiency may sway your decision when it comes to decorating your home. This research takes time and patience, but there's good news!

We’ve consolidated all relevant information into a comprehensive blinds vs. curtains guide for your convenience. Here are the pros and cons you need to know when searching for window coverings that will best suit your needs.

Read more
These Christmas table decorations are the perfect backdrop for your holiday meal
Take your Christmas table decorating up a notch with these fun ideas
Festive Christmas table setting

'Tis the season to send our tastebuds on an adventure. Maybe you'll serve turkeys and hams or maybe you'll whip up some unique side dishes and decadent Christmas desserts made from recipes passed down throughout the generations. Either way, food certainly takes center stage this time of year. However, who says your taste buds have to have all the fun on December 25?
Christmas table decorations can provide a feast for the eyes (and make your family and Instagram followers swoon). While some may think of it as another item on their to-do list, you may love getting your creative juices flowing by curating a gorgeously arranged tablescape. Allow these ideas to serve as inspiration.

Tell your turkey or roast to move over. Making room on your table for a centerpiece will draw attention to the table (rather than smartphones). You have plenty of options, from subtly beautiful assortments to statement pieces. Consider these ideas:

Read more