Skip to main content

21OAK may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

How to choose the best fall lawn fertilizer for a lush yard in spring

Here are some amazing fertilizer options to use this fall

When summer comes to a close, it’s time to find the best fall grass fertilizer for your grass to keep your landscape looking healthy and strong come spring. Winter can be harsh on your yard, and the last thing you want is a barren or muddy landscape once spring finally arrives. Thankfully, there are plenty of “winterizing” lawn fertilizers made to treat your grass to ensure it’s healthy and lush as the weather starts to warm.

However, while there are many brands to choose from, not all fertilizers are created equal. What fertilizer should you use in the fall? We’ve rounded up our favorite lawn fertilizers to help you control weeds and maintain fresh, green grass throughout spring.

Leaves being raked

What fall fertilizer does for your lawn

A common misconception by homeowners is the idea that all fertilizers work in the same way. However, that is far from the truth. Fall fertilizer doesn’t perform the same functions as spring fertilizer. Fall fertilizers are often made to improve healthy root growth, add nutrients and minerals back to the soil, prepare seeds for frosts, drought, or heat, and encourage new growth in the spring.

When using fall fertilizers, most people intend to “feed” the lawn to retain nutrients within the soil. Additionally, many homeowners pair their fertilizers with new grass seeds in order to take advantage of the nutritional benefits for seedlings to sprout by next spring.

Below are some of our favorite fall fertilizers. Each performs a different function depending upon your needs.

Soil and fertilizer comparison lawn care

Espoma EOFW30 Organic Fall Fertilizer

If you’re looking for organic fertilizers, Espoma is a brand that avoids using harsh chemicals or byproducts within their fertilizer. This fall fertilizer is made of feather meal poultry manure as its main component. Sulfate of potash is another key ingredient that allows Espoma to stand out amongst the rest. This ingredient introduces natural potassium and sulfur to your lawn to encourage the production of healthy soil nutrients.

What’s most impressive about this fertilizer is that it has water-soluble and all-natural components. There is no reason to worry about harsh chemicals being drained into nearby water systems, as the materials are all non-toxic and organic.

Blue house in autumn

Jonathan Green & Sons

Jonathon Green & Sons fertilizer is best for homeowners who are eager to plant grass seeds that will grow next spring. For barren and dry landscapes, planting seeds in winter can allow the grass to take root and sprout. However, winter frosts and excessive moisture can hurt seeds, hindering them from growing in the spring.

This fertilizer by Jonathan Green & Sons encourages root growth and creates optimal conditions for seeds to grow next season. You can add this fertilizer to your lawn before or after you have scattered the seeds. Over the winter months, the grass will take root and provide nutrients that benefit plant growth.

Lawn fertilizer in wheel barrow

Scotts Turf Builder WinterGuard

Scotts Turf Builder is a great fall fertilizer to add nutrients and security back to your soil. As the seasons change, the soil is prone to drought, overheating, and frosts that damage roots. This fertilizer aims to prepare roots for winter by strengthening them so that once spring arrives, they can provide a lush green carpet across your lawn.

This fall fertilizer is specifically meant for feeding your lawn and promoting healthy root growth. While it doesn’t kill weeds, many lawn care experts recommend using fertilizers that encourage stronger grassroots over those that aim for killing weeds.

Handheld fertilizer for lawn care

What to know when fertilizing your lawn

Before fertilizing your lawn, there are a few things you need to know.

First, fertilizers can perform two different functions. They can prevent the growth of weeds, or they can feed the preexisting grass in your yard. Some fertilizers have been able to do both, and those are considered “weed and feed” fertilizers. While killing weeds is often the main attraction for many homeowners when fertilizing their lawn, many experts argue that feeding your lawn and creating strong and healthy grassroots is far more important.

It’s also recommended that you follow fertilizing instructions to prevent overfeeding your lawn. Overfertilization can cause your grass to turn brown and die, which is the opposite of your goal when using fertilizer. Many fertilizers perform best when spread across your lawn at the recommended measurements. Additionally, it’s best to wait four to six weeks between each fertilizing session.  Preventing overfeeding isn’t just good for your lawn — this reduces the risk of fertilizer runoff, which could end up polluting your local waterways.

Typically, you only need to fertilize twice in the fall season. If you choose to fertilize once, use a product with a high proportion of nitrogen. If you fertilize twice, use a nitrogen-rich fertilizer the first time and a potassium-rich fertilizer the second. (All fertilizers are labeled with three numbers, which represent the ratio of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium.)

While there are specially made fertilizers for every season, fall fertilizers tend to better benefit the health and wellness of your lawn’s soil. They add a solid foundation for root growth and prepare seeds to sprout in the spring. Be mindful to follow the directions on your fertilizer’s packaging to ensure you are not over or under-feeding your lawn.

Editors' Recommendations

Amelia Wilson
Amelia Wilson (pen name Amelia J. Wilson) is a content writer in Greenwood, IN. She enjoys topics on productivity…
Use these natural, chemical-free crabgrass killers to take back your overgrown lawn
How to eradicate crabgrass without chemicals
Tall grass

You work hard to keep your lawn pristine and immaculate, so a weed infestation is an incredibly frustrating issue. Crabgrass is arguably one of the most frustrating weeds. It's invasive and extremely difficult to eradicate, and it can take over your grassy oasis in the blink of an eye. It produces hundreds of thousands of seeds per plant and can grow in all areas of your lawn—from the lushest, sunniest spots to the barest, darkest corners.

Treating and killing crabgrass can be handled easily with tough chemical treatments. But if you want a more natural crabgrass killer that doesn't require using substances that can be harmful to your lawn and your family, you've come to the right place. Here are some ways to eradicate crabgrass without the chemicals.

Read more
When you should (and shouldn’t) put used coffee grounds in your garden
coffee grounds mixed in the garden compost bin

Depending on how into gardening you are, you may be aware that putting used coffee grounds in your garden is a highly debated topic. Some people swear by using coffee grounds for growing plants, while others say it's the worst thing you can do for your garden. So which opinion is correct, and how do you know which side to trust? How do you know if you should – or shouldn’t – put used coffee grounds in your garden? We’ve researched the pros and cons for you and break them down below so you can decide how to use coffee grounds in the garden.

Should you use coffee grounds as mulch?
Using mulch in your garden can be beneficial, but many people find the cost of mulch too expensive to turn into organic matter. Straw and compost can be used as mulch, but not many people have tons of straw lying around, and compost takes months to create. So it seems as though coffee grounds would be the perfect solution for gardeners in need of mulch.

Read more
How to kill dandelions and keep them out of your lawn for the entire season
how to kill dandelions featured resized

Dandelions may look pretty when they first grow, and kids sure love them once they turn to fluffy balls of seeds, but ultimately, they are bad for your lawn. If you have a yard, you have undoubtedly encountered these pesky weeds. So, how do you kill them without killing your grass and keep them from coming back over and over? We’ve got some easy lawn care tips for you below so you can kill dandelions and have a weed-free plot that all of your neighbors will envy that lasts the entire season.

Learn about the enemy
The first step to killing dandelions for good is to educate yourself. Dandelions are part of a subset of weeds called broadleaf perennials, and this variety of weeds is notoriously difficult to remove. The main problem is that once a dandelion plant fully establishes its 10-inch taproot, the weed will come back year after year, hence the name "perennial." Not only does the pesky plant come back year after year, but it also spreads its seeds around your lawn continually, thus creating more and more weeds.

Read more